Woman Complains About Having to Wear Formal Attire to Barn Wedding

A woman has sparked debate online about black-tie wedding expectations.

In a post on Reddit’s “Wedding Shaming” forum, a woman shared her confusion over recently being invited to a barn wedding with a black-tie dress code. She questioned whether or not it’s appropriate to expect guests to get dolled up in formal attire “without getting the black-tie experience.”

“This is so wild to me,” she wrote. “Couples these days have completely lost the plot on dress codes. Does no one close to them tell them this is insane? Is this a result of most couples planning their wedding themselves without family involvement or a professional planner? Is social media giving people unrealistic expectations? Google is at your fingertips to research these kinds of things.”

She first complained that the wedding venue wasn’t up to black-tie standards.

“The wedding is going to be at a venue that is a renovated barn. It looks lovely, but it’s still a barn,” she wrote.

Although the woman insisted that she’s “in no way shaming them for their wedding plans and budget,” she frowned upon the bride and groom’s plan of having a “cash bar.” She also argued that a formal affair should have a seated dinner, not comfort food “served from food trucks.”

“In some ways I feel bad for the couple,” the woman said. “Most of the couples in our circle had actual black-tie weddings. I’m wondering if they maybe feel some pressure because of that.”

She added of the bride in a comment, “It makes me feel bad as I think she may be comparing her budget to everyone else. It’s about celebrating the marriage and a life time of love! This is a longtime friend of mine and I would be happy to celebrate her marriage anywhere or anytime. Social media has really skewed how people think about weddings.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

In the comments section, many Redditors speculated that the bride and groom might not fully understand what black tie means, or that they’re overcompensating for guests who they worry won’t dress up whatsoever unless they state a very formal dress code.

“People just don’t know what black tie means and don’t even Google it,” one person wrote, with another individual adding, “I think a lot of couples inflate the dress code as they know some people who will dress below the dress code.”

Someone else commented, “I just figure most people don’t actually know what the different tiers of event attire are, and that most people see ‘black tie’ and think ‘formal with suits and nice dresses,’ and not ‘tuxedos.’ “